Martin Sheen – He’s very liberal, so he’ll fit a high percentage of the political profile here. And he has a kid who’s a mess, so I’m sure he has questions to ask.
Johnny Depp could be interesting. The wide range of (often offbeat) roles he plays seems to show a quirky personality, and he’s definitely got a brain. Plus he can be pretty outspoken at times.
James Dean. He was edgy for his day, but supposedly he also had a great sense of humor and style. I think he would have liked Fluther and would have contributed well with his rebellious streak.
I think a young (comparatively speaking) Jim Morrison would fit in well here, the one before, during and shortly after his time at UCLA, before he helped start The Doors.
Fiddle Playing Creole Bastard Not in my fantasy Fluther they wouldn’t! Besides, when you say something with wit you can practically get away with murder!