I have no opinion on the whole economy thing.
—
In respectful disagreement with some of my esteemed Fluther colleagues…
Taxes on corporations do one thing: increase the cost of making product. That cost is passed on to the consumer.
The point is to realize that the government can indeed limit the profits of corporations, but it will not decrease cost to the consumer. So therefore, what’s the point, except the redistribution of monies… which is not a job of the U.S. federal gov’t.
It seems to me that people feel that the oil companies are price gouging. Price gouging is illegal… but that’s not what’s happening here. Devaluation of the dollar as well as supply & demand are the key influencers. The supply problem is directly due to the energy policy of the America that prevents U.S.-based companies from drilling anywhere new. Hell, the Chinese are drilling less than 60 miles off the coast of Florida, but we can’t. And going by environmental-impact track record, that’s not the way you’d want it to go.
And since when is making a profit a bad thing? The oil companies’ profit margins aren’t really that far out of line. Percentage-wise, Apple is even higher (15% vs. Exxon’s 11%). And oil companies have massive R&D and engineering costs… the whole industry is speculative in nature and hence, risky. Big risk and big rewards go hand in hand.
I understand using taxes as a tool to help coerce companies/states/people to go down a particular path… but using them purely to punish success and redistribute wealth (which is the rhetoric most often used when discussing oil company profits) strikes me as completely wrong, reactionary, and pandering to class division.