General Question

RandomGirl's avatar

I hurt my wrist practicing the piano on Saturday. What should I do for it?

Asked by RandomGirl (3362points) May 16th, 2013
11 responses
“Great Question” (2points)

Yes, yes, an injury from piano… Bizarre, I know ;)

I twisted and stretched wrong because I was learning a knew song and didn’t know where exactly my hand went. It instantly hurt, although it wasn’t bad enough that I had to stop practicing right away. I thought I had just stretched a muscle a bit farther than I usually do, and it’d be sore for a few minutes and then go back to normal. So much for that. I realized I had actually injured myself on Sunday morning, when it started really screaming at me. I used a heating pad on and off all day Sunday, because it made it feel a lot better. Monday was fine, and I thought I was back to normal, but when I went to my piano lesson on Tuesday, it flared up again and my mom bought a brace like this for me. I’ve been wearing it on and off for the last two days, and I’m starting to realize my wrist/hand isn’t getting better, although the brace helps.
So my questions are:
-How can I know for sure whether or not it’s carpal tunnel? It seems to fit everything I’ve read on the internet, although a friend told me it absolutely cannot be carpal tunnel because I’m only 16. It seems to me that anyone who does repetitive movement (like typing or playing the piano) without being careful to always move properly can have this happen. So can I definitively say “that’s not it”?
-What else is there besides carpal tunnel? I really don’t know much about wrist injuries. Articles to read would be helpful.
-Is there anything left that I can try on my own to help it recover? Or have I tried all my options and should go to the doctor?
-Should I be wearing the brace all the time? Only when it hurts? -Should I be pushing it and trying to do everything I can without hurting, or should I completely let it rest?

Observing members: 0
Composing members: 0

Answers

Cupcake's avatar

I take my son to an orthopedist every couple of months for injuries. I don’t believe in messing around with teens and bones/joints.

Please go to the doctor. An orthopedist. They will do x-rays and evaluate you. They will come up with a treatment plan and follow-up to make sure you are improving. They will write an order for physical therapy, if necessary.

janbb's avatar

Let it rest. Wear the brace at night and for comfort during the day. You can alternate icing and heating it – 20 minutes on, 20 minutes off. It might be carpal tunnel but time will tell; it sounds from the suddenness like it is more likely a sprain.

But I agree with @Cupcake. Talk to your doctor.

RandomGirl's avatar

OK, thanks… I’ll see when we can get to the clinic. I’m just about on a first-name basis with some of the nurses. ;)

Cupcake's avatar

My son fell in gym on Tuesday. His wrist hurt more as the day went on. I brought him to the Orthopedist at 6:40pm (their urgent care clinic closes at 7pm). They took x-rays and diagnosed him with a sprain. He has a proper brace and a note excusing him from gym. He is to keep the brace on for 2 weeks solid, then up to an additional week as needed. He has a follow-up appointment in 3 weeks.

He was out of the office at 7:15pm.

Believe me… it is out of many sprains and broken bones that I give this advice. We’ve been to the pediatrician, urgent care, emergency departments, etc. Your best bet (quickest and cheapest) is directly to the Orthopedist.

Good luck!!

JLeslie's avatar

Wear the brace and let it rest. Carpal tunnel is usually from repeated action and usually does not come on suddenly, it happens over time. Either way, carpal tunnel, sprain, muscle strain, prescription is rest the wrist. Rest includes not lifting anything heavy. After a week or two of having it basically immobile and not lifting anything, then you can start using it again, but still no heavy lifting and no extreme usage for several days as the muscle stregnthen again. You can also take ibuprofen for a few days initially to relax the muscle and decrease inflammation. Two pills (400 mg) every 6 hours. Three pills if you weigh over 140 pounds. But, if rest seems to be working well, then taking mediciation could easily bebtotally unnecessary.

Disclaimer: I am not a doctor.

elbanditoroso's avatar

I have to ask: Is this a major pain, or a minor pain? Is it a sharp pain?

At age 16, it is unlikely to be carpal tunnel syndrome. Remember that the hand is a whole lot of very small muscles (and tendons, and other connective tissue), to say nothing of the bones. So excessive practicing can over stretch (or run raw, or otherwise inflame) a muscle or a tendon.

Rest is a good idea. A brace is fine for immobilization, but don’t try to practice and wear the brace, because the two will work against each other.

A good way to reduce inflammation is to take Advil, but not every person’s body can tolerate it (it can upset your stomach and/or cause constipation), so check with a parent or doctor.

Best thing you can do is not stress the muscles there.

marinelife's avatar

You should see a doctor. It’s possible you’ll have to stop practicing until it heals (or it won’t heal). Also, you should have iced it not used a heating oad after injuring it.

JLeslie's avatar

Oh, about the ibuprofen/advil make sure to take it with food and a glass of water, I don’t care if it is two crackers, some food to help prevent any adverse stomach irritation as mentioned by @elbanditoroso above.

RandomGirl's avatar

Thankfully, the pain isn’t really a problem, because I can’t take ibuprofen or advil (they give me heartburn). We’re planning on getting in to a doctor soon, and I’m taking it easy. Thanks, everyone :)
@marinelife Seems like I always manage to do the exact opposite of what I’m supposed to do in these situations – I use heat when I should use ice, and ice when I should use heat! :/

JLeslie's avatar

@RandomGirl Then next time don’t use heat or ice. Ice is usually when an injury immediately happens, but there are conflicting theories on heat or ice on these sort of things 24 hours after the injury.

Inspired_2write's avatar

Take Ibuprofen and stay off the piano for two weeks .
Also writing and typing etc ( activities that aggravate ) stop doing.
I had to use a wrist brace then a elbow brace etc but it did nothing for me!
I was off work for five months until all feeling came back into my hands,as before that I had lost Alll feeling and use of my hand!
Some people just continued to use there wrists and ended up permanently loss of the use of there hands!
I was diagnosed with tendonitis and carpal tunnel but later I believe it was bursitis?
Still do not know yet.
I had been on Ibuprofen for five months and did not realize that this promoted weight gain due to the lower metabolism!
So use it for short periods of time.
I used heat pad too for relief, which felt better for me. Some people use ice,if that works
you?
I had overworked my hands doing too many hours at my job plus using my hands in other activities like embroidery ,writing,keying/typing,household chores ( cleaning oven,washing dishes,windows etc) which can also take a toll on your body too.
I have since quit my job and retired last year as my wrists still cause pain at times and I now have Arthritis too.
It is much better now that I have eliminated all causes so far
I rarely take meds for pain now except in certains situations where I had over used my wrists and body ( hiking) too much.
Good luck, but if after two weeks of rest you find that pain returns then go see a specialist to determine its true cause.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

Mobile | Desktop


Send Feedback   

`