Ex-vegetarian (had been for 9 years).
When @ninjacolin asks “Should we eat animals”, he’s probably not asking:
– Should we eat animals if we want to maximize flavor for tonight’s dinner.
– Is it legal to eat animals?
He might be asking:
– Should we eat animals if we want to be healthy?
But more than likely, he’s asking:
– Is it moral to eat animals.
I think it really depends quite a bit on many variables. But it’s fairly easy to present a situation that can be evaluated. Person A:
– lives in a location with access to a wide variety of healthy, non-meat foods (U.S.)
– has enough income that purchasing non-meat items does not cause any real financial hardship.
In this case, eating meat is completely unnecessary. So, any suffering that exists as a result of Person A’s eating of meat seems to me to be not necessarily justified.
Now, we could add other variables into the mix, such as eating cage-free, cruelty, free-range animals that were not raised in factory farming environment, or animals that were hunted. This would certainly change the dynamic of the discussion here. But I’m not sure how we could get around the fact that in some situations, a living creature is going to be killed for simple pleasure (how they taste).
Note:
– I’m not excluding myself here. I was a vegetarian for 9 years, but have consumed animals since 2000 and completely have the means not to.
– I’m not talking about people in other cultures or poor people here in the U.S. who simply need any food.