Social Question

LostInParadise's avatar

Should the history of math and science be taught in K-12?

Asked by LostInParadise (31913points) March 10th, 2014
14 responses
“Great Question” (6points)

Sometimes it seems as if schools deliberately teach math and science so as to make it as dull as possible. I think it would make these subjects much more interesting if, as part of a math or science course, some historical context was given. It should not take up a lot of time and it should not be included as part of the tests.

I am mostly familiar with math. Here is a list of some of the things that I would include in math courses. What else should be included? What should be included in a history of chemistry, physics and biology?

1. Brief introduction to math of Egyptians and Sumerians. Explain that since there was no algebra, math was taught by example.

2. Importance of Greek math. First development of formal proof and idea of axioms. Controversy of Euclid’s parallel axiom. Brief introduction to non-Euclidean geometry and explanation of its significance.

3. Development of so called Arabic numbers by mathematicians in northern India, including use of zero and negative numbers.

4. Work of Arab mathematicians in advancing algebra and disseminating work of Indian mathematicians .

5. Work of Italian Renaissance mathematicians in solving third and fourth degree polynomials. Demonstration of how these equations can be solved. Work of Abel and Galois in showing that there is no general solution for fifth degree and higher order polynomials. Very brief introduction to abstract algebra.

6. Discussion of the dramatic development of math in 17th century Europe. Napier’s logarithms (show how these relate to slide rule), work of Fermat and Pascal in number theory and probability, Descartes’ analytic geometry, and discussion of impact of the calculus of Leibniz and Newton.

After the 17th century, it is hard to keep track of all the things that happened. Perhaps a discussion of Euler’s development of topology and an introduction to the work of Gauss.

Observing members: 0
Composing members: 0

Answers

Tropical_Willie's avatar

I was taught most of your items in Jr. High and High school, also Venn diagrams and logic. However I was in advanced math classes back to the late 1950’s to mid 1960’s.

LostInParadise's avatar

I am impressed. I was not taught any of this. Association of development of logic and Venn diagrams with the work of George Boole would be a good idea.

Cupcake's avatar

Not until college.

JLeslie's avatar

I was taught some of the history during my education k-12. I don’t remember what grade, maybe some in 6th and some in 7th? My memory isn’t clear. I don’t think it helped me with being able to do math. I think it is good to know some of the background. They taught some of it when we studied Roman Numerals, and learned how to use other devices for doing math in history before calculators.

Edit: Also in 10th grade I remember learning more about how the sciences developed.

dxs's avatar

Ehh. A lot of people tend to struggle in math anyway. I’m tutoring middle-schoolers and it’s already enough focus for them to learn the material. I think it could be a separate class from a math class, and definitely at least 9–12+. Do you think this will help students with their math at all? (Having been through high school and currently in my second semester of college, I haven’t even learned this.)
With science, that’s much more broad and so it depends on what science, so save that for at least high school when you start taking more specialized sciences.

dxs (15160points)“Great Answer” (1points)
JLeslie's avatar

Abacus. Ugh, I couldn’t think of the word until now.

Tropical_Willie's avatar

We also did “base-seven” and binary.

jerv's avatar

I always found math okay, science fun (especially physics), but history boring. While I can appreciate the logic behind knowing the roots and evolution of math, I feel taking more than a few minutes on it would put kids to sleep. It won’t really help them actually do the science either; at least math helps with physics, and physics allows one to do fun stuff.

LostInParadise's avatar

I was thinking of doing history of math for at most a few minutes per class, but I am not convinced that students would find any more to be boring. It is not just historical context but also providing the human side. For example, I think it is kind of fun to know that the Pythagoreans were a cult that believed that the universe is based on ratios of whole numbers. It proved to be a bit upsetting when one of the members showed that the square root of two is irrational.

ibstubro's avatar

Awesome question! It’s been in my ‘Questions for you’ folder for a day or so, and I neither answered nor opened it. “Borderline.”

NOT!

The only thing I disagree with it ” It should not take up a lot of time”. I think the History of Math would have hooked me. Brought me in. Ancient Egyptians? HELL YEAH.

Eventually schools will integrate subjects. Students will be required to write an intelligent treatise on the history of math.

JLeslie's avatar

@ibstubro I hate the way they are intergrating subjects for very young children. For older kids I am ok with it.

pleiades's avatar

YES! Goddamn. I have always wondered, “who introduced this, and why? and what is mainly used for today.” Goddamn. Instead I’ve been forced to suck it all in and memorize formulas when all my poor brain wanted to do is take it back a step further and learn the history of it all, and how these formulas are applied in todays real world.

ibstubro's avatar

I totally agree, @pleiades. Rote, boring formulas be damned. Show me the evolution and I might even find the next step.

NanoNano's avatar

The history of science if often worked into any science degree in college, as a way to build a foundation on what you are required to learn. (For instance, in chemistry, physics and astronomy, you learn about all the changes that have occurred over the centuries to get us to where we are today).

So not sure if that should be relegated to K-12, but it is being taught.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

Mobile | Desktop


Send Feedback   

`