General Question

Polaris's avatar

Do songbirds express creativity?

Asked by Polaris (74points) May 19th, 2016
4 responses
“Great Question” (3points)

Is what they do properly considered as “creativity”, in more or less the same sense as a human – say while making something up ‘catchy’ on the guitar. Kind of mimicking things you’ve heard, but absolutely trying to step beyond that to a place where the newness takes over and delights, for whatever reason.

This is regarding this crazy ginger House Finch in the tree outside my window, looking at me and really giving me what for.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=scQaOoIdmj8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FntoLQqhTBQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QmI9W9c2Zk

Observing members: 0
Composing members: 0

Answers

Coloma's avatar

Possibly, this is more mimicing behavior than actual creative ingenuity but….I had a damn Mockingbird that learned to mimic my phone one year. I would go running to answer it and realize it was the bird in the yard, it was uncanny how he/she sounded EXACTLY like my phone. lol
I know the pair of House Finches that nested in the corner of our big front porch here were quite creative, building their nest in a tangle of light cords that formed a little pocket at the end of the porch from where the deck lights all connect. It was the prefect cradle.

Rock-a-bye birdies. haha

Pachy's avatar

I’m no avian expert, but I would think they sing reflexively rather than creatively—yet no less pleasingly to human ears.

flutherother's avatar

Birdsong is creative and sounds more fresh and original than most noodling on a guitar. Let’s not forget however it is meant for other birds and perhaps God rather than us humans.

Mariah's avatar

Ask the bower bird!

Less exotically, song sparrows are an interesting bunch. They have a complex song that isn’t uniform among the species but varies between individuals. I notice that for the most part their calls start and end with a series of rhythmic notes, but in the middle it’s a free for all of trills, buzzes, and other interesting sounds.

I pass lots of them on my walk to the train station and I’ve started to notice that there’s one individual who’s a little…..how should I say it…...special. Rather than the elaborate trilling and fancy cadences of his fellows, in that middle part of his call he just sticks one long, low, loud BUZZZZZ. It’s ugly as hell and I keep wondering if he’s going to get a mate or wind up lonely because of his lack of creativity. I found it so funny that I recorded it a few days ago.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

Mobile | Desktop


Send Feedback   

`