Bagels are sold every day at this resort in St. Croix:

http://www.antillesresorts.com/2sapphirebeach.htm

I don’t know how far away from Havensight that St. Croix is, but if it is a very far distance, the folks at the resort may be able to give you the name of a place in Havensight that sells them.

Also, I imagine that grocery stores in Havensight would carry them in their bread section, although those would probably need to be heated in a microwave oven, to restore their “fresh from the oven” taste and texture.

You originally asked this question in 2007, so I am guessing that you have probably gotten an answer by now, from another source.