I am stumped and I feel like I really know their work.

I am stumped, too. I thought I knew all of their songs.

“Punky’s Dilemma”
Wish I was a Kellogg’s Cornflake
Floatin’ in my bowl takin’ movies

I think Art had the day off. ~

Sorry, all I could think of.

So – what is it @marinelife Are both of these “close but no cigar” or is one what you were thinking of?

I think Willy’s comes closest.

Was it flavored with parsley, sage, rosemary and thyme?

I believe it was Punky’s Dilemma although I had thought it referred to alphabet soup. Thanks all.

I’m pretty certain that @Tropical_Willie nailed it with “Punky’s Dilemma”, but on the off chance that there might be something else, and while searching, I came across this delightful interview with Art Garfunkel.

@CWOTUS Thanks for finding and sharing.

@CWOTUS Interesting. I think they both have personality flaws. But they did make beautiful music!