Wow – this is a tough one. I am going to say that Fred Taylor is the way to go. While both Taylor and Fargas are technically the “starters” they both have guys behind them that are bigger threats in McFadden and MJD. Still, the Jaguars are a great team, and the Raiders are most certainly not. I like Taylor to gor for 80–90 total yards and a score vs. the Titans. I don’t see Fargas doing that. Go with Taylor.