[Mod says] In the guidelines, the general rule is quite clear:
”All content must:
Use proper English (no txtspk)
Be spelled correctly
Use appropriate punctuation”
I agree that the later ”don’t take it personally if you have a question pushed” is a bit misleading. I have no idea when these guidelines were written (certainly before my time), but I would guess that the phrasing is a response to user behavior. We don’t get a lot of complaints about answer moderation, probably because having a question pulled can seem very personal. We’re also less aware of guideline violations in the answers, and probably more inclined to let a questionable post stand to avoid disrupting the discussion – so having an answer removed is less noticeable as well as less common.
That said, here’s an excerpt from our top secret moderation handbook that removes all doubt:
”Interpreting the guidelines (answers):
‘Txtspk’ should be removed immediately, and the user sent a warning PM. Misspellings and bad grammar are acceptable to an extent if English is not the user’s first language, and they manage to get their point across; but we do still send PMs to encourage them to use their best effort.”
@SQUEEKY2 ”And shouldn’t we be given the chance to correct the writing if it is so important in a answer?”
Ideally, yes, but Fluther isn’t designed for that. We just don’t have a way to push an answer back to the jelly in question. That’s why we try to walk a very fine line. We do not remove answers with a single typo. When there’s txtspk, though, or multiple errors, that’s clearly in violation of Fluther’s guidelines.