some people ask the OP why they’ve asked that or just make comments that are irrelevant to the question itself. Some reply with even more questions and not a single answer.
Your problem is that you assume that all questions in the General section are straightforward, easy-to-answer ones.
A lot of questions require debating and critical thinking, things like politics, philosophy or morality. These kinds of questions can’t be answered with just a straightforward response, and there will always be different opinions that clash with each other. But that is what debates are for, to exchange ideas.
I had a debate with someone recently about whether the Covid virus was a bioweapon. Our debate went like this:
The person: do you Covid is a bioweapon designed by China? I think so!
Me: suppose that claim is true, what is their purpose for making the virus?
The person: to sell drugs.
Me: and what kind of drug did they push out? And when did they make it?
The person: uhh… I don’t know. There are so many countries out there making drugs I can’t keep track of them all.
Me: that’s the point. There are so many countries making drugs. Moreover, the first vaccine to be announced didn’t even come from China. So if their goal was to sell medicinal stuff, they were failing miserably. How the hell could they compete with so many countries when they couldn’t even come up with a vaccine first?
I asked questions throughout the debate, but I was answering the main question the entire time. The questions were to help guide the person to my point. Now are my questions considered off-topic by your standards?
Some assume stuff that is not even there.
And why do you think it’s not there? Did you ask for clarification or source of the claim? Sometimes a wild claim actually has a lot of merit if you are willing to look deep into it. It could come from a logical but flawed place, or it could even be something true that just happens to sound crazy. And that is exactly where the exchanging of ideas comes from, to help everyone understand things from different perspective.
If you hate Fluther for not answering questions and want a place where everyone is always on-topic, I suggest the StackExchange website. They have a very strict rule that literally everything has to be in the format of question/answer. Answers have to be directly related to the question or they will get deleted. There are a lot of categories on the website for you to choose, from programming to history to relationship advice. But you also have to make your question as unambiguous and straightforward as possible or your question gets deleted. And also you have to do your own research and show them what research you have done before you can ask questions I don’t know if it’s true in every category, but it’s true on my history board.