I thought that the first 80 pages were entirely too long. I thought that the latter portion didn’t really accomplish what it claimed to accomplish. I think that the entire thing was poorly written, and there were a couple of oddities that were used entirely too much (e.g., They start laughing and Mack laughs along but doesn’t know why, or Mack suddenly realizing how much he loves Jesus [how many times can that happen within 15 pages?]). I think that it relied a lot on raw emotional manipulation, while managing to avoid actually being compelling.
I like this review and this review.
I don’t think that the book is nearly as ground-breaking or revolutionary as it seems to think that it is. I think that it is both overpraised and overcriticized (for theological reasons, that is). I don’t think it deserves nearly as much attention as it gets from its lovers or from its haters. I don’t think that it’s hard to see why no one wanted to publish the book.
(I’m a Christian, by the way, if that has any bearing on anything.)