@Les: <3
Into the Woods, it was the first one I was in.
A Chorus Line, it was the first I ever saw, I was I think seven or eight.
Cats, the second I ever saw.
The Phantom of the Opera, the third.
Wicked, for the whimsy.
Stomp, for the funnies.
Rocky Horror Show, because, duh.
Two by Two, Danny Kaye was a bona fide genius. He gets forgotten too often.
RENT, the first I ever saw on Broadway. Followed within a few days by Cabaret starring Molly Ringwald as Sally Bowles.
I could not choose between these, all Broadway is love for me. And there are so many, many, more.