I don’t think this is a simple question. If your question is “which do you think is better?” then it would be a legitimate simple question. Right now though, the question is “which IS better?” and that all hinges on how you define better.
South park does more commentary on current social events whereas Family guy is just funny.
Family guy is funnier. However much as perchik said south park does more skits on current events to show how screwed up the world has become.. nerds 4 life :-)~
Nerding or Nerdering? You probably meant Nerding, but Nerdering (meaning you left off a letter instead of adding an extra letter) has a certain appeal as a new word. Oh wait, you said no over analyszing. Sorry. Family Guy.
Futurama, but South Park absent that choice. Family Guy is funny, but I prefer some semblance of a plot over consistently cutting away for a throwaway joke.
family guy because stewie and brian are hilarious and peter is lost louise meg and chris are just kinda there ya kow. But everyone on that show is funny.