Once a man met my general criteria – intelligent, not too heavy, not cocky, not a stupid joke-teller, kind, taller than I – I always checked out hands (nail biters always made me shudder and still do) and arms. A penis without a smart, sweet guy attached to it is pretty boring…
Hands is my thing. You should take care of yourself, hygiene, looks etc. A good firm well-toned body clean shaved and smell nice is absolutely turn-on!
I would have to say eyes, teeth, and the V-shaped muscle on the lower abdomen (that Zina mention above) I love that part of a mans body. Also, the lips.