Social Question

rooeytoo's avatar

Should Women Fight on the Front Line?

Asked by rooeytoo (26981points) September 13th, 2009
16 responses
“Great Question” (1points)

The controversy regarding the ability of women to fight beside men on the front line of a military conflict has risen its head once again in Australia.

http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,,26047312-2702,00.html

I personally think it should depend upon the individual not the gender. Perhaps one should be required to pass a test of strength? I have known women who were mentally and physically capable of going up against most men and men who did not have the physique or mentality for combat.

I know in a perfect world there would be no military conflicts but since this is not a perfect world, what do you think?

Observing members: 0
Composing members: 0

Answers

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

Yes, of course.

dpworkin's avatar

A person who wishes to be assigned to combat, and fits the required norms for the activity should certainly be free to participate in the defense of her country.

I should not say only “her”. It is also imperative that we don’t lose the services of willing homosexuals who wish to honor their nation, just because of our own narrow prejudices.

benjaminlevi's avatar

Only if they want to be.

Sarcasm's avatar

Absolutely.
I understand why they weren’t allowed to, back in the day, when there were actual battles, since women (generally speaking) lack a lot of muscle mass that guys do have.

But now, doesn’t matter how muscular you are, just point and click.

Ivan's avatar

Of course, you already have to pass a “test of strength” to fight on the front lines anyway. Your stance that women should have equal opportunity to take this test is the exact same thing as saying that women should be able to fight on the front line.

oratio's avatar

Well, we’ll have to put it to practice to know how that works out. There is no point of being for or against something you know nothing about. I am all for letting women pulling their weight in combat. It would probably work. If they make it through training, why not.

rooeytoo's avatar

@Ivan – well do they have equal opportunity to take the test? I was never aware there was a test, is it only physical or psychological as well?

tinyfaery's avatar

Of course. Those who choose to go into combat should always be ahead of drafting the unwilling.

Ivan's avatar

@rooeytoo

I was referring to basic training.

azhaiaziam's avatar

heck yah… who cares what they got between their legs…

Ansible1's avatar

I agree that it should depend on the individual and not the gender, and yes I believe that women should be able to serve on the front lines. That being said, I am also understanding of those who disagree. It’s often said that when at war, the only thing a soldier has is the soldier next to them. This topic always reminds me of that scene in G.I. Jane, I’m not sure of the exact wording but goes something like:
“You know, the Israeli’s tried it – women in combat….seems they couldn’t bear the sight of a woman blown open. They would linger over the wounded females, trying to save those who obviously couldn’t be saved, often to the detriment of the mission.”
I must admit that if I were in combat and saw females getting “blown open” I would be much more distraught than if it were fellow men. Is that wrong? I don’t know that’s just how I feel. I’m all about equality, and if a woman chooses to enter front line combat, she should be able to.

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

@Ansible1 it’s not ‘wrong’ that you feel that way but it is a socialized response and bringing women to the front lines as well as teaching all our children the value of human lives, no matter the gender are ways to change socialization

rooeytoo's avatar

Lurve to everyone for your answers and it is good to hear that most are in favor of equality in all arenas.

augustlan's avatar

Add my vote to the ayes. Anyone who makes it through basic training out to be fit for battle.

knitfroggy's avatar

If a woman wants to then she should be allowed to.

mattbrowne's avatar

Surviving on the front line requires intelligence above all, so women fully qualify.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

Mobile | Desktop


Send Feedback   

`