Fashion is pretty far outside my range of interest and expertise. I don’t spend any time dressing or undressing any celebrities or thinking about what they wear, except what I see in magazines of popular culture that I look at in waiting rooms. What seems funny to me is that I can’t detect much of a pattern in which attire draws scathing mockery (like these) and which is extravagantly praised. Usually most of them look pretty weird or stupid to me, and you could swap all the captions around and they would make just as much sense.
I think the main reason fashion writers pick on celebrities is that they know their audience is going to love seeing them get trashed—not all of them, just enough to keep it believable: “Hey, if somebody like Demi Moore and so-and-so (who are some of those people?) can {get picked on for her appearance | look like an idiot in public | have a bad couture day | commit a breach of good taste | blow it big time}, maybe I don’t have it so bad.”
But I don’t happen to think that this particular selection is unattractive. I think the drape is very lovely, classical, and someone with the right figure (such as someone other than me) can get away with that exposed leg. The fact that it is really halves of two dresses, a long-sleeved gown on one side and a sleeveless tunic on the other, makes it kind of interesting.
But I think the color is awful and is indeed just about potato colored. I don’t think there is a more useless color in the world than taupe, not even beige. I think if this had been done in, say, a deep emerald green, it could have been a beauty.
But, as I say, this is an altogether non-fashion-savvy opinion here, so take it for what it’s worth.