Maybe cut a rubber glove into small squares & then layer them, glueing them together. Then once that big square of layers dries, cut out the size you need & pop it in. That is my immediate thought. If I think of another, I’ll write back.

If it’s a Zippo Windproof Lighter, Zippo will repair it for free

Your lighter will be repaired at no charge and returned promptly, usually within 5 – 6 weeks.

Our Repair Clinic performs excellent repairs at no charge. Please do not attempt to perform repairs yourself, as it could damage the lighter beyond repair.

Don’t you need a receipt?

Nope; no receipt needed. Look at the website. They have very specific instructions as to how to pack and send the lighter. Zippos come with a lifetime guarantee.

Sweet, thanks.