Fluther: What is God?

Malachi 3:6 “For I am the LORD, I do not change;

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Yes but when he sent jesus down he gave what none has done before he gave forgiveness

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

and as time goes on things evolved and so things got tossed out what was needed no longer

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (3

)

17“Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. 19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven,

Words of Jesus, Matthew 5:17

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (1

)

* stretches *

Got any more?

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (5

)

@battousaikeller I am confused as to why enslaving someone for any period of time is ok. Six hours, six days six years, no one should be enslaved, the God of your Bible (which should really be called Man’s Bible because whether it is the word of God or not, it is the word of God filtered through the perception of men and there is no denying that the men who wrote the Bible had an agenda) seems to approve of this treatment. I am also confused as to what Jesus bringing forgiveness has to do with God approving of slavery.

SuperMouse (30845

)“Great Answer” (1

)

yes he was talking about himself of the prophesies that were written about him and about the law he did fulfill the law because he was perfect

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Why dont you people try reading the whole bible and just stop arguing over something that is never going to end…!

Brenna_o (1779

)“Great Answer” (1

)

The Law is the Law of Moses. Anyone with half a brain knows that.

@Brenna_o

I’ve read the Bible more than my own ex-pastor. So have many of the atheists on Fluther and around the rest of the world.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (3

)

right and didnt jesus fullfill that law to show he is perfect

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

I have read the Bible. Multiple times. I know plenty of Christians that have NEVER read the Bible.

I suspect if more people actually read the Bible, fewer people would be Christian.

@battousaikeller I’m not seeing this perfection you’re describing.

ANef_is_Enuf (26839

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Jesus was first mentioned in Isaiah. – correction… EMANUEL was first described in Isaiah.

Moses had nothing to do with Jesus. Jesus, however, was a Jew, who followed and supported the law of Moses.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

christ is sinless he never broke one or more of the commandments

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

* facepalm *

That has nothing to do with the Law.

You’re talking in circles, and not even doing so intelligently.

Let’s see if I can spell it out for you:

Slavery in the Bible = still slavery.
Oh, but that was a long time ago.
God doesn’t change
Jesus came to change it
God doesn’t change. Jesus even said that God doesn’t change
No, Jesus meant that he was sinless.
WTF?

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (4

)

so what are you exactly want to know

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

I don’t want to know anything. I already know what the Bible says, and why it’s all bullshit.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

but its not

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Prove it.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

i dont need to the bible speaks for itself

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Woop woop go @battousaikeller !!!

Brenna_o (1779

)“Great Answer” (1

)

To me, the Bible says

Kill anyone I don’t like (heathens, pagans, homosexuals, witches…)
I’ll kill the people I do like (Job’s family)
People who don’t like me will burn in hell for eternity.
Mutilate your children (circumcision)
Kill your children if they disobey you
Sell your daughters into slavery
Women are property
Children are property
People who don’t follow your god are property
Rape is justifiable
Jesus had violent tendencies

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (5

)

right god does not like anyone who does not follow god knew their hearts and saw wickedness and wouldnt stand for it

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

back then yes because there was no government system like we have today

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

And we’re back to

Malachi 3:6 “For I am the LORD, I do not change;

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

and rape was never justifiable

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

yes he never changes but we do

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

I’m sure the wife of Onan’s brother was completely willing to have her husband’s four brothers attempt to bed her within the week. And Bathsheba was dying to betray her husband to his death in order to marry King David.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (1

)

he gives mercy where mercy is due

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Torn between satisfacton and chagrin at the ruckus he’s raised, @hawaii_jake slips out the back, taking his six pack and pretzels with him. ;-)

Trillian (21148

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Stop spouting useless BS and respond with some semblance of intelligence to what I’m actually saying, please.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (1

)

bathsheba never knew

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Funny, because David screwed her before her husband got home. She obviously knew something was going on.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

@battousaikeller
You see, that is the problem. People know the Bible is BS, because it makes claims that are factually wrong.
It did not get the emergence of earth and life right.
It did not get the shape of the earth right.
It did not get the makup of the atmosphere right.
It did not get the setup of the solar system right.
It did not get species classification right (it claims that bats are birds).
It is not even internally consistent.
It has two different creation myths that are incompatible with each other.
It has two incompatible stories about Jesus’ resurrection.
It has two incompatible stories about where Jesus taught (a field vs a mountain)

Yes, the bible does speak for itself. That is why it proves itself to be BS.

ragingloli (51958

)“Great Answer” (1

)

@ragingloli
Don’t you know all those scientists are being lied to by Satan?

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (1

)

@Brenna_o You’re killin’ me.
I was going to leave it alone @janbb, I swear I was. I was ignoring the spelling, or lack thereof, I was ignoring the crap out of the punctuation, or lack…. then I saw….THIS; ”...not Gods will that any shall perish and goto hell. But the only way to get into HEaven is through his father Jesus Christ. Eventhough we are all sinners…”
I believe that for the sake of all of us here we’d appreciate all being on the same page, so let’s make clear that most Christans believe that Jesus Christ is God’s SON, not his FATHER. Are we clear?

Trillian (21148

)“Great Answer” (1

)

ok no she wasnt there David was fearful because she was preganot (sp)

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

there 4 different gospels their were reprters who got it from witnesses and hear say but jesus did say blessed are those who dont see and still belive

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Oh, you want to get into the Gospels?

How about the fact that only two of them state that Mary was a virgin? And Luke – the DOCTOR – wasn’t one of them!

Now, I know if I witnessed the birth of a child to a virgin, that would be damned interesting. Wow! Born by a virgin! And now, the apostle who should have been MOST interested didn’t even mention the fact in passing.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

@Trillian Jesus is Gods son yes…

Brenna_o (1779

)“Great Answer” (0

)

he didnt have to

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

This is kind of interesting. I’ve read some of Dr. Ramachandran’s work before, he’s really fascinating. Anyway, here’s this tidbit;

SCIENTISTS believe they have discovered a “God module” in the brain which could be responsible for man’s evolutionary instinct to believe in religion.

A study of epileptics who are known to have profoundly spiritual experiences has located a circuit of nerves in the front of the brain which appears to become electrically active when they think about God.

The scientists said that although the research and its conclusions are preliminary, initial results suggest that the phenomenon of religious belief is “hard-wired” into the brain.

Epileptic patients who suffer from seizures of the brain’s frontal lobe said they frequently experience intense mystical episodes and often become obsessed with religious spirituality.

A team of neuroscientists from the University of California at San Diego said the most intriguing explanation is that the seizure causes an overstimulation of the nerves in a part of the brain dubbed the “God module”.

“There may be dedicated neural machinery in the temporal lobes concerned with religion. This may have evolved to impose order and stability on society,” the team reported at a conference last week.

There’s more of course. Here’s a link if anyone is interested:
http://cas.bellarmine.edu/tietjen/images/new_page_2.htm

Trillian (21148

)“Great Answer” (2

)

it was prohesied by god that yes his son was going to be born of a virgin

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Response moderated (Personal Attack)

is it not true

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Ew, I despise when people post scripture as an asnwer to anything – have your own answer please..you’re plagiarizing

Anyway, @Rarebear @Seek_Kolinahr reflect my views on this construct – which is what god is.

Simone_De_Beauvoir (39052

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Is what not true?

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

did not god say that his son was going to be birthed by a virigan

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

scripture is truth

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (1

)

@battousaikeller Please keep your regurgitation to one comment, thanks

Simone_De_Beauvoir (39052

)“Great Answer” (2

)

I believe that is mentioned in Isaiah – not by god, but by a prophet. Which makes it all the more startling that Luke would make no mention of the prophecy’s fulfillment.

However, the topic at hand is the evil, violent nature of the Old Testament God, and the fact that Jesus reinforced the laws of that god. Can we get back to that?

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

God created darkness for his own purpose so what

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

So, you support the malevolent, genocidal, racist, sexist, inconsistent god of the Bible? and you believe it is completely acceptable to own slaves, treat women as property, kill people who do not worship your god, etc?

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Actually, he did not.
In fact, Jesus does not fulfill the criteria to be considered the messiah.
http://www.jews4judaism.org/jewsforjudaism/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=374:messiah-the-criteria&catid=68:the-jewish-messiah&Itemid=481

ragingloli (51958

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Would it be wrong to follow the laws about owning slaves?

Would it be wrong to stone nonvirgins to death on their wedding night?

Would it be wrong to kill unbelievers?

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (0

)

yes I can

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

acctually Jesus did

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

This is just stupid, now.

tinyfaery (44084

)“Great Answer” (5

)

now yes

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

He did not. Read the link.

ragingloli (51958

)“Great Answer” (0

)

I think we’re still in denial that someone can be this dense.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (2

)

prove to me in scripture that he didnt

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

So you’re a moral relativist?

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (0

)

Scripture is spelled out for you in the link @ragingloli provided.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

as I said, read the damn link. Spelled out on it for you.

ragingloli (51958

)“Great Answer” (0

)

Be nice, fellow atheists.

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (2

)

* breathes * Sorry, @Qingu . Fixed.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (1

)

ok see hes coming again

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Whether or not jc fulfilled the prophecy in the gospels is a moot point. The gospels were written decades after jesus died and the authors made up a bunch of stuff about him anyway.

In Zelda: the ocarina of time, there’s a prophecy at the beginning of the game, then later, the hero ends up fulfilling the prophecy. This doesn’t prove anything since, like the gospels, Zelda is largely fictional; anyone can write a fulfilled prophecy narrative.

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (2

)

and jesus was talking about setting a spirual kingdom not a physical kingdom

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Strange how the one question no one is supposed to be able to answer has over 150 responses in a matter of a few hours. Or maybe it’s not strange at all.

zophu (5711

)“Great Answer” (0

)

the prophecies were written decades before jesus

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (3

)

What does any of this have to do with BibleGod being Hitler’s role model?

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (0

)

Wait, you never answered. Are you a moral relativist?

Why would gods morality change?

Why was it okay to own slaves and kill unbelievers in 33 ad but not 34 ad?

Are you saying Jesus abolished these laws?

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Jesus was supposed to return before all of his followers died. He said so himself. And then all his followers died and he still was not back.
Not to mention that the messiah is supposed to achieve all his objectives in one life time, not in a second coming.

ragingloli (51958

)“Great Answer” (1

)

I suggest watching an informative debate between Sam Harris and David Wolpe: http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=sam+harris+vs+david+wolpe&aq=5
Most theist/atheist debates are a circle like this one (where the religious person ignores facts), but rabbi David stuck in there pretty long with the philosopher/neuroscientist Harris.

Blackberry (33949

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Yes, anx the stories about how Jesus fulfilled the prophecies were written decades after he died. Do you believe everything you read?

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (1

)

yes jesus did when he died on the cross he took the worlds sin from their past present and future

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

You think Jesus abolished the law?

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (1

)

what do you mean by abolished

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Abolished = don’t count no more.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Finshes drink. Stands up. I’m a little disappointed hat the Christian side is not better represented here. I hope everyone does not take these two as models. I know one scholarly man in particular who would have some good answers that actully address the questions being asked. I don’t know if he would convince anyone of anything, but he would at least let you know that he does have a thorough knowledge of the bible and would manage not to make an idiot of himself. I’ll check back later.

Trillian (21148

)“Great Answer” (5

)

Abolished as in, you shouldn’t follow the laws anymore.

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (0

)

in a way yes the law is their to prove that we are sinners and that we do need his grace and mercy and that we need forgiveness

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

GOD is whatever created the big bang

iRemy_y (550

)“Great Answer” (2

)

God is a made up being. His purpose is to help people to feel that life has a meaning. People want to believe in a god, b/c they can’t accept that they will one day be gone, and the life that they lived meant nothing.

Afos22 (3990

)“Great Answer” (3

)

So you disagree word for word with Matthew 5:17.

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (0

)

god is a spirit

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (3

)

no i dont that was him saying im fullfilling the law to prove im gods son and that the prophesies about the messiah i will fulfill

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

@battousaikeller I honestly believe that you would be doing yourself and your Savior a favor if you stopped playing on this thread. At least before you post anymore read well this well thought out and very coherent post on a similar subject.

SuperMouse (30845

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Ok. So would it be good to follow the ot laws, or not? You keep on waffling on this.

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (0

)

the ten commandments yes and the 2 other commandments that jesus gave

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

I think he thinks “law” means the same thing as “prophecy”. Like Matt 5:17 isn’t discussing two completely separate topics at the same time. He also seems to think that the only Law of Moses is the ten commandments – not the entire Pentateuch.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (1

)

But the other 603 laws that god gave us would be immoral to follow?

Btw, the tenth commandment allows slavery.

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (0

)

it doesnt allow slavery at that time there was

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

“Slavery” isn’t a person that hung around for a while and went away.

It’s a social construct that existed and was encouraged by Moses in the name of BibleGod.

And only Hebrew slaves (yes, they were allowed to enslave each other) had those lovely rules we discussed earlier. All the women and children that were left alive after the Hebrews wiped out every male of fighting age and every non-virgin were taken as slaves – no indentures there. That was by order of your god, not passive “Well, if you have the slaves anyway, might as well not covet your neighbor’s”.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (3

)

right

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Well it says not to covet my neighbors slave. Paul also says you can own slaves in 1 Tim 6 and elsewhere.

But ok. You never answered my question. Immoral to follow most of god’s laws today? Yes or no?

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (1

)

i belive so because we have no use for them

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

i have to go

battousaikeller (145

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Interesting. You think god gave us immoral laws.

Why did jesus say you’d be “greatest in heaven” if you follow them and teach others to do the same?

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (0

)

Likewise. Farewell.

Qingu (21185

)“Great Answer” (0

)

@battousaikeller STOP spamming the thread!

Simone_De_Beauvoir (39052

)“Great Answer” (3

)

Yo mama

evandad (2495

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Yo mama so religious…........

Blackberry (33949

)“Great Answer” (5

)

All I have to say is that there is an infinite universal power that is interconnected.

I do not adhere to fundementalist christian beleif, but….I do adhere to universal law and there is truth in that, in the oneness of all creation, sans the argument of whether or not the creator is the biblical ‘God.’

I have had far too many sychronistic experiences to doubt for a moment that when one is open, present and in touch with source, amazing things happen.

I like the mantra of ” it is not see it and you will believe it” it IS ” believe it and you will see it.”

The power is there for everyone, but…. if you do not seek, you will not find, it’s that simple.

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (5

)

@Coloma I just want you to know that I think that nothing needs to be glorified in order for it to have true meaning.

zophu (5711

)“Great Answer” (2

)

True.

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (1

)

The concept of a God is whatever someone wants it to be. This includes believers and non-believers.

YARNLADY (46379

)“Great Answer” (2

)

@Coloma Far out.

FutureMemory (24753

)“Great Answer” (0

)

@Coloma I like your little mantra. A lot of people seem to see things that aren’t there simply because they want to believe it. Kind of like the old Discordian parable of the man who found patterns in the fragments of a shattered boulder, and from that came to believe that there was some sort of purpose behind it that made sharp stones align in triangles and white stones in helices.

FireMadeFlesh (16593

)“Great Answer” (1

)

@FireMadeFlesh

Mock me if you will… there’s a whole other unexplored dimension beyond science and logic…find it or not. ;-)

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (3

)

God for me has become the life force energy that provides the living spirit in all living things. You can feel it all around you if you simply tune it in and it is a spiritual moment when you do!

Cruiser (40449

)“Great Answer” (6

)

@Cruiser

ZING!

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (0

)

God is what gives Jedis power.

cockswain (15276

)“Great Answer” (3

)

I used to think that Isaac Asimov was god.
@Cruiser, you rock.

Trillian (21148

)“Great Answer” (3

)

@hawaii_jake – did you ever dream you would get 208, 209 if you count mine, responses!

I heard a guy in a meeting say one time, he wouldn’t define his relationship with his new girlfriend because it would “set parameters, and assign limitations.” I don’t know if that is true but it sounds good and I would say the same thing about this god creature.

But as I have said before, I believe in insurance so when something good happens, I roll my eyes heavenward and say a silent thank you. Cuz, you just never know!

rooeytoo (26981

)“Great Answer” (2

)

God is a big blinding light. You can’t not look at him you will go blind. That is just my imagination talking.

Frenchfry (7591

)“Great Answer” (1

)

My version of a higher power is the energies within the universe. Both spiritual and physical.

shpadoinkle_sue (7188

)“Great Answer” (1

)

@rooeytoo : No, I never imagined the thread would be like this, and it makes me want to scream, “I had an awesome date that lasted all afternoon and evening while some poor people were jerking around on their computers.”

@everyone : Thank you. I’m sorry. I promise not to do that again.

:)

turns his back Thank god that’s over. whips back around No wait! I didn’t mean that like it sounded! Oh no! Don’t start that again!

Hawaii_Jake (37335

)“Great Answer” (3

)

.

zenele (8257

)“Great Answer” (4

)

“We are all atheists about most of the gods that humanity has ever believed in. Some of us just go one god further.” –Richard Dawkins

“So far as I can remember, there is not one word in the Gospels in praise of intelligence.” -Bertrand Russell

“We must question the story logic of having an all-knowing, all-powerful God, who creates faulty humans, and then blames them for his own mistakes.” -Gene Roddenberry

“If it turns out there is a God, I don’t think that he’s evil. But the worst you can say about him is that basically he’s an under-achiever.” -Woody Allen

“Is god willing to prevent evil but not able? Then he is not omnipotent. Is he able but not willing? Then he is malevolent. Is he both able and willing? Then whence cometh evil? Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him god?” -Epicurus (341–270 BCE)

ipso (4481

)“Great Answer” (5

)

@Coloma I was not trying to mock you, I just wanted to point out that the saying goes both ways. In the end belief may or may not correspond with reality, but it cannot affect reality.

FireMadeFlesh (16593

)“Great Answer” (1

)

Hmmm, religion provokes vitriolic bile & hostilities!! Now there’s a suprise.

ucme (50047

)“Great Answer” (3

)

@ucme the people involved would have something to do with it.

BoBo1946 (15325

)“Great Answer” (1

)

“He spoke to me about His home in heaven”

So there is rain in heaven. Does it get too cold or too hot? Do you have to have a door to lock?
Or privacy from nosy neighbors? Walls to hang your possessions on?
What would be the purpose of a home in heaven?

That’s putting mans face on God.

And, its murder not kill. They never got around to fix that one.

Also, I see God when I look at all of you.

“I am done arguing with you people.”
There are no arguments on Fluther. Mods will not allow it. :-)

Good sold debating. God to love that stuff.

CMaz (26303

)“Great Answer” (2

)

God is the English name given to the singular omnipotent being in theistic and deistic religions (and other belief systems) who is either the sole deity in monotheism, or a single deity in polytheism. Wiki

Read a lot of threads, not all. Don’t think anyone can fully explain who God is or isn’t. Personally, i just believe. I take it by faith. Sure, many things about the Bible that even theologians cannot fully explain. If you try to intellectualize Faith or God, it will not happen. It must be accepted as a little child would.

I’ve lots of questions unanswered, but will never, not believe because of things that have shaped my life. I don’t believe in God because I’m afraid to go to Hell. Just understand and believe in his goodness and mercy in my life. Sure, like everyone, see all the misery in this World, but i don’t question God’s plan.

Having said this, see so many evangelist on TV that give religion a bad name. The Swaggers, Tilson (cannot remember his first name), Baker, etc. It is a personally thing with myself. Don’t go around comdemning others or proselytizing my religion. Mine is done in the quietness of my home.

Believe me, I’m not an All-American Christian, but, as i always have said, i’m a good waterboy on the team.

BoBo1946 (15325

)“Great Answer” (3

)

@BoBo1946 Oh absolutely!! Nothing wrong with religion or faith. I myself have no interest but to each their own. It’s just that some have a tendency to shove their views down each other’s throats. Just an observation, funny really.

ucme (50047

)“Great Answer” (2

)

@Cruiser-hmmmm—heard this somewhere before…..—;)

lucillelucillelucille (34325

)“Great Answer” (1

)

@FireMadeFlesh

Gotcha…you’re a hard one to ‘read.’ lol

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (0

)

‘God’ is a feeling, I feel ‘God.’

I feel ‘God’ right now on this magnificent summer morning, I literally FEEL every molocule in my being blending right into the rays of the sun as they play across my shady little canyon.

‘God’ is not a mental construct, a being as most are taught, ‘God’ IS pure energy, universal energy, the stuff of stars, the perfect totality of everything, AND…when I am fully in touch with this magnanomous force, miracles happen.

My desire to live in this river community and the co-correspondant feelings/imaging of such led me to this house, sealed the deal on a handshake, and it was mine in an afternoon!

Oh yeah…I am living proof that when one is in congruence, the planets do line up in ones favor. Expect miracles and you will get them, expect unhappy outcomes and you will get those as well.

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (3

)

Someone asks “what is God?” and people argue over the Bible and Judeo-Christian beliefs. The question wasn’t “Are the Bible and Judeo-Christian beliefs valid?” Arguing over another’s beliefs doesn’t really answer the question. It only proves a strong opinion for or against another’s beliefs.

If I were to post my beliefs, and someone were to argue as a means to discredit those beliefs or to get me to change my beliefs, it would neither prove or disprove the existence or validity of God.

A real test of God’s existence is not found in the persuasive arguing of words. Any fool or brilliant person can argue – it neither proves or nullifies anything.

I would rather want to know how one lives the words, the argument. Say you’re an atheist? Fine, how do you live without a god? Say you’re a born-again Christian? Ok, does the love of Christ affect everything you say and do? So, you may be of some other religion or belief system. How does the God of your life change you from being just an ordinary person living an ordinary life?

You who argue with words, what aspect of your life is any better or worse because there is or is not God in it?

I cannot prove or disprove with words the existence or validity of God. However, I can show you my life – what it looks like with I live with God and when I choose to live without God.

Having had both experiences in a very intimate sense, having lived in both directions, I have seen along with others around me that there is a difference between the two. God is not someone or something I could ever create – although I am creative and imaginative, the God I know supersedes my limits. The God I know doesn’t need my Bible or my words to find existence or validation. Yet, the God I know somehow survives the weak attempts of man to prove or disprove His/Her/Its existence.

Talk about life, and you talk about God – no matter what you believe. Don’t agree with me? Ok. No problem. I didn’t prove God to you, and I know you won’t disprove God either.

whatnot (589

)“Great Answer” (10

)

@whatnot

” I can show you my life- what it looks like when I live with God and when I choose to live without God.”

ZING!

Yep, I think inner peace speaks for itself, I always have people saying they want some of what I have, I tell them it’s theirs for the taking, I am not ‘special’, I just know the ‘secret’. ;-)

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (3

)

@Coloma “I literally FEEL every molocule in my being blending right into the rays of the sun as they play across my shady little canyon.”

Literally? That’s a number with a lot of zeroes.

cockswain (15276

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Say you’re an atheist? Fine, how do you live without a god?

I act for the betterment of myself, my family, and those around me. Not because I will be “rewarded” for my good deeds or “punished” for my bad ones, but because it’s the right thing to do.

I do not teach my child abstract concepts and lies that will confuse them in the future. (“What’s that?” “Rain and Thunder”., not “What’s that?” “The angels are bowling and God is crying”) or encourage belief in things without evidence. (Santa Claus will be a character in ”‘Twas the Night Before Christmas”, just as Willy Wonka is a character in “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory”.)

I do not live under the assumption that people who do not believe the way I do are inherently evil, are criminals, are going to burn in hell, get multiple abortions because they relish foetal death, etc. I do, however, find it sad that so many people devote their time and large percentages of their family incomes to a deity that probably doesn’t exist. I do mourn for people who live in the bondage of their religion whether by choice or by edict of law, or the insistence of their families. I become angry when I hear of children dying because their parents decided to pray instead of seeking medical attention.

As when I was a Christian, I spoke to all who would hear about the perceived goodness of my god, I will now do all I can to help others with questions follow those questions to their logical conclusion—and I won’t even have to deal with the internal guilt that leading others to a lifetime of guilt and oppression once did.

Seek (34805

)“Great Answer” (8

)

Hey, frequencies ya know? lol

Yeah, yeah, what can I say…you either feel it or you don’t.

Everything is made of the same stuff, just arranged a little differently.

Yes, sometimes I can literally ‘see’ the molecules in the air…it’s a hum, and it is visible.

I travel in my own little high frequency zone… ;-)

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (3

)

@Seek_Kolinahr ” will now do all I can to help others with questions follow those questions to their logical conclusion—and I won’t even have to deal with the internal guilt that leading others to a lifetime of guilt and oppression once did.”

Excellent. A standard argument is that people are born in a state of sin and without god, they would be evil and sinners. With that logic, we atheist would be committing all sort of horrible crimes and murders and the “saved” would live lives of peace and harmony. I guess that the Crusades, witch trials, bombing in Northern Ireland, and suicide bombing, and genocide in Serbia are just anomalies and didn’t really happen.

The problem with the “Revealed Religions” is their ability to send non=believers to hell up to the point where they can expedite that trip. Thank god we are not a Christian country.

Ron_C (14480

)“Great Answer” (5

)

Religion and spirituality have absolutely nothing in common, except the common misnomer that they are somehow one and the same.

There was no Christianity before Christ. Most of religion is a manmade construct, and about as far from the teachings of Jesus as one could get.

It has been said that if Jesus were alive today he would not be a ‘Christian.’

There is, however, an infinite source of power, call it universal law or whatever floats your boat, and it is real, one only has to tap into the eternal source that is within everyone.

Infact I just finished reading ” Faith and science in Orthodox Gnosiology’ and one thing that I found very interesting was the suposistion that if….

” Christianity were to appear for the first time in this era, it would have taken the form of a therapeutic institution, a hospital to reinstate and restore the function of man as a psychosomatic being.”

I LOVE that!

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (5

)

@Coloma I like what you’re saying. I think of God as just whatever the universe actually is, but don’t like using the word “god.” That is too closely associated with what I consider to be just dumb ideas and mythology, and conflicts with the way things actually are. Some have similar experiences to yours, just kind of an open-minded appreciation and connection to energy, but then try to link it to the bible or whatever. This is where I end up getting really frustrated with people who believe this. It’s like they take what could be a pure learning experience and pervert it to religion and try to cram it in to fit something it isn’t. It’s kind of like quitting, not trying to continue to understand how things work even further. Like if I saw my remote control and just said, “I guess that is just a magical object.”

But I’m with you on the energy concept, that’s what appears to link everything. The closest I come to accepting any sort of philosophy is Taoism. All it really talks about is appreciating and trying to harmonize with energy. That’s a concept that I can get behind.

You say “I am not ‘special’, I just know the ‘secret’”. What are you talking about? This is where I can get hung up, wondering how much of my contemplation and meditation ends up being hallucination and imagination due to biology and mental blocks. Kind of hard to describe, but when trying to understand what truly is I end up suddenly doubting myself and thinking “hey, is this real or am I imagining it at this point. Where are the physical limitations (and thus delusions) of my brain, if any?”

I don’t know. If anyone has any ideas, I’d love to hear them. To me, all religion is full of handicaps and blocks. People may become religious trying to seek higher understanding, which is noble, but my opinion is that is eventually a dense thicket. I’m even wary of using the term “spiritual” for similar reasons.

cockswain (15276

)“Great Answer” (4

)

@cockswain I thought that was the midichlorians…

Dr_Dredd (10540

)“Great Answer” (3

)

@cockswain : You wrote: when trying to understand what truly is I end up suddenly doubting myself and thinking “hey, is this real or am I imagining it at this point. Where are the physical limitations (and thus delusions) of my brain, if any?”

I wish I could help. I truly wish I could, because I have much the same question. When I meditate, am I tapping into a source higher than myself or am I deluding myself?

I have experienced things in and out of meditation that defy logic, and I choose to believe that there is something larger than me that I am tapping into. But…Yet…I still doubt.

My modern education causes me to question. I question my own senses at times and wonder if what I experienced was real or hallucinated.

Maybe I need to take up yoga or seek out a yogi.

Okay, Universe. This student is ready. Where is the teacher?

Hawaii_Jake (37335

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Yes, the Tao and Buddhism resonates with me the best as well.

The ‘secret’ is to be in touch with your being, to drop the wild horses of mind and bask in beingness. When in this high frequency state of no thought, stillness ‘speaks.’

‘The small still voice’ cal it ‘God’ , Buddha nature, whatever works for you.

I do not have an issue with using the word ‘God’..although, I agree, ‘God’ is the most overused and abused word ever, well…maybe next to ‘love.’ lol

When aligned with appropriate ‘desire’ and the co-correspondant feeling state one manifests that which one puts the most attention on.

Quantum physics supports this truth, ( not theory, TRUTH ) ;-)

Like Sam Clemens said…’ A man is just about as happy as he makes up his mind to be.’

To put the ‘spiritual’ spin on that quoate, I’d say ’ Man is just about as close to ‘God’ as he UN-makes up his mind to be.’ lol

What we resist persists, resit finding ‘God’ and you will be succesful. ;-)

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (4

)

@Coloma and I believe indentically. I read her post and was astonished how much we’re alike. But I dont know if she also feels we have it “easier” than most because of personal experiences which are available to all who seek them. Why? I do not know. How it works? I do not know. But these experiences are wonderful. and personal

Aster (20023

)“Great Answer” (2

)

@Aster

Yes. And usually one must have a spiritual ‘crisis’ so to speak, the process of alchemy.

I know when my ego was totally busted wide open, and through that suffering I was put in touch with the peace that passeth all understanding. :-)

This crash was many years ago, but I cannot express the profundity of my transformations and subsequent connection to something so much greater than the small selfs need to see itself as a separate and powerful being.

Hah!

Oh sweet surrender.

Btw….the more you effort at your meditations the more you miss the point…the ‘just this-ness’...it’s already always here, now. ;-)

Be here now, that is all. And in being here now, fully awake in the present moment, you allow the magic to work through you! ;-)

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (3

)

@hawaii_jake I think admitting you have a problem definitely helps. I agree with everything you said: where is the difference between delusion and truth? I think sometimes people contemplate Christ, or Yahweh or Allah and have an exciting sensation that arises from contemplating large concepts and infinity. I believe people confuse this “spiritual” feeling with having originated in the deity he/she was contemplating. And that is a delusion. “Where is the teacher?” Intellectually, I understand it is in all of us. But how does one maintain such an attitude? I might walk away from this computer and get pissed off about something dumb.

@Coloma Your quantum physics point is colossal to me. Ever since I heard the Heisenberg Theory (you can’t ever be certain of anything since the act of observing an event influences its outcome) I’ve felt that is the way the energy of our atoms and quantum particles is connected to the universe. Our brains and thoughts must be similarly connected it seems. This, the math, physics, and beauty of it, is the path. Some condemn science for its lack of spiritual depth. I believe it is trying to practically define and explain all spirituality. How much have our lives improved by just improving our understanding of electricity? Imagine if we could understand the physics of thought.

@Dr_Dredd midichlorians are undoubtedly comprised of quantum particles. Even though I hate magical, supernatural thinking, the idea that we could willfully influence quantum particles with the correct mindset could evolve into Sith lords and Jedis.

cockswain (15276

)“Great Answer” (4

)

@coloma “Btw….the more you effort at your meditations the more you miss the point…the ‘just this-ness’...it’s already always here, now. ;-)
Be here now, that is all. And in being here now, fully awake in the present moment, you allow the magic to work through you! ;-)”

Sure, I’ve read that too. Putting it in action has always been my, and doubtlessly many others, dilemma. But I do feel I’m better at it now than 10 years ago. I feel I’ve developed a really healthy open-minded pessimism ;- )

cockswain (15276

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Yes, taming the wild horse of mind is a constant, no magic poof, practice makes perfect.

An excercise I like to employ is to be fully present with every movement, task, no matter how small or mundane, being in a fully present state of ‘mind’ allows the just this-ness to show up.

Presence ( attention ) is the key to fully living in totality.

Our minds are like radios, most people wander around in a static zone, not fully tuned into to a high frequency, lost in the ( as the Toltecs say ) ‘metote’...the ‘fog.’

Keep your attention, full presence, on everything in the moment, just walking, just watering, just looking, just SEEING, minus the intrusive mind chatter and rote conceptualizations.

I love to observe animals as they are the true Zen masters….just looking without thought, fully present and through that wonderful, natural presence right action always flows, effortlessy!

The bird on the branch does not think about the next branch it wishes to alight on, it is simply present and when it moves, it’s movements are always perfect, in total congruence with it’s needs in the moment.

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (3

)

@Coloma Yeah, life isn’t about a destination, or about being on a path to that destination; it is a frequency of being. People who have lost the ability to feel that are stuck in their point-to-point’s, until the only point left is somehow Afterdeath. It doesn’t matter where you will go, if you are harmonious with nature, you are where you need to be.

zophu (5711

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Nice answer, @Seek_Kolinahr.

Yes, well said!

To everyone:

Great discussion, I love to chew the spiritual fat so to speak, but NOW…I have a goose thats been promised a swim in the draining hot tub…one must keep their promises ey?

Time to put my attention on fun in the ‘big, big, tubby!’ lol

Let it be a great day to all!

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (2

)

I do think you have to qualify it, though. “Anything he is incapable of understanding” would have to include evil and suffering, and mankind does not usually give that the name of God.

I usually avoid questions on this subject because their rationality quotient tends to run so low, but there were some interesting responses here. Also I do look in from time to time just to remind myself of what we committed atheists are up against.

Jeruba (55824

)“Great Answer” (3

)

@Coloma I’m jealous )-:

Aster (20023

)“Great Answer” (2

)

@cockswain It sounds like your views on “god” are very similar to mine. Like I said I do not believe in some “omnipotent old man” hiding above the clouds waving his fingers “creating” things from nothing. The concept of “god” to me is more like a self-aware universe or “cosmic consciousness”.

I do not believe in “magic” or the “paranormal”. I believe in ghosts, spirits and some type of afterlife realm that interpenetrates our dimension. To me its not “magic” or “above science” but this concept to me is more like another part of science we are not familiar with yet. I believe the concept of “god” or the “paranormal” is a part of quantum physics not magic. Can I prove this? No. Its what I believe however.

Jabe73 (4010

)“Great Answer” (4

)

@Jeruba

I see no need to label anything. Isn’t this THE reason for all discord, personally and globally, egos need to set divisive boundaries where none need to exist?

‘The rationality quotient” is an arrogant statement implying that you have a monopoly on truth.

Is that so?

” Anything that he is incapable of understanding ” would have to include the not understanding of ‘spiritual’ truths as well.

The truth of non-divisive being and temperance of ego.

In other words, getting out of your OWN way so that space is made for something divine enter.

In the words of the late, great spiritual author James Allen ( As a man thinketh )

” The Christian condems the athiest, the atheist satirizes the Christian, the Catholic and Protestant are ceaselessly engaged in wordy warfare, and the spirit of strife and hatred rules where peace and love should be. Until you can regard people of all religions and of no religion with the same impartial spirit, with all freedom from dislike, and with perfect equanimity, you have yet to strive for that love which bestows upon its possessor freedom and salvation.”

Wise words indeed.

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (4

)

“Evil” is only sick ego run amok.

Not some netherworldly demonic force set out to wreak havoc on humanity.

Suffering and ‘evil’ are part of what is, and they have nothing to do with spiritual truths.

Stuff happens, and it is perfectly possible to have a deep spiritual connection and accept the ways of the world as well without feeling the need to cast out those unsavory realities in the world of form.

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (4

)

I think it’s that people get into so much stress, they have to make their worlds small enough to deal with; so they start sticking labels on things. This makes things easier to conceptualize and manipulate, but it tends to keep things too stagnant to adapt efficiently. So we have to find ways to deal with the stress of the natural world while also dealing with the stagnant labels people used in the past to deal with their stress—which I’m slowly coming to accept as being a part of the natural world as well.

The most annoying problem is though, a lot of the obsolete labels are still being used by people who fall into stress today. And that’s not their own doing. There’s some sick stuff going on in how so many people are influenced in such ways. It’s like a constant bad-note playing in the back of my head. I just have to make sure I don’t fall into the same trap and start calling it evil.

zophu (5711

)“Great Answer” (3

)

Well said.

Yes, moy definition of ego is one who is mentally, emotionally and spiritually bereft.

This opens the door to all ‘evil’ conduct, petulence, greed, hatred, envy, and the force field of dark emotionality that drives one to commit grievious acts to satiate their unwell inner beings.

The constant, unremittant grinding ‘need’ for more, more, more..be it a substance, power, monetary gain….this is the sickness of humanity.

A total disconnect from self.

Damn…hate to leave this discussion again, but..I have dinner guests in an hour…gotta let the wine breathe, along with myself. lol

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (4

)

@Coloma Well, don’t make ego the substitute for evil. Like you said, it’s sick ego that causes problems. People label their egos, make them something unchanging—“immortal” even. Those egos become disconnected from the constantly changing world and, you’re right. They can be the central source for a lot of unhealthy stuff. But essentially, an ego is a part of a person’s self and not a bad thing.

I have at least three myself.

zophu (5711

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Agreed, yes, to clarify, it is sick egoic function not ego itself, which has it’s place as a survival mechanism.

But I do believe that it is unhealthy ego that perpetrates what some call ‘evil’, rather than a separate entity called the ‘devil.’ Altough ego caqn be devilishly clever in it’s myriad disguises. lol

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (2

)

@Jabe73 I like your idea of the universe as being self-aware. Honestly, I never looked at it that way but it behaves so dynamically, why couldn’t we call it “alive?” Self-aware? I can’t answer that. What I sometimes wonder is could we view the universe as evolving? Is it changing, improving, and removing flaws? I’ve heard physics tends to break down at a sub-atomic level, and I wonder if this is only because we just don’t understand those laws yet, or if there are little imperfections in the universe. Like how our bodies aren’t perfect, they have immune systems, but they aren’t foolproof and we age and die. Or is the universe completely perfect at this and all moments? Who knows, not me. Probably depends on how you define perfect I suppose.

I’m with you on the idea of ghosts and spirits really just adhering to laws we don’t yet comprehend. However, having never personally witnessed a ghost, and unable to adequately define a spirit, I don’t know that they actually exist. It gets beyond my scope of understanding, but physics implies multiple dimensions existing, and they would have to interweave with ours. If you speculate spirits are penetrating our dimension, that sort of gets back to the idea of the universe having little imperfections, like that is something that is an error in the usual way things work.

Regarding an afterlife, I’ve really been struggling with the concept. I think most religion is founded on the fear of there being zero self-awareness after death, so we create ideas to comfort ourselves, and sometimes tie it to behavior. Obviously I (nor anyone) know what happens to our consciousness at death, so to me it seems silly to imagine we do. I just figure whatever it is is subject to the quantum rules of the universe and will also happen to me one day, as it has countless lifeforms before me.

On sort of a side note regarding the afterlife, I had a thought a while back that has really been nagging me: how do we know Hitler didn’t suffer the same fate as Gandhi after death? We don’t. A selfish, greedy, complete asshole, or a pedophile, could in all possibility have zero consequences for a life of terrible behavior towards fellow man as the kindest, most loving amongst us. This concept troubles me a bit, but it may be possible the universe works this way. Do “nicer” wolves or geese get a better afterlife that meaner ones? Do ants get any different experience than us, if any?

cockswain (15276

)“Great Answer” (1

)

I think it all comes down to compassion.

The way of the world has always included atrocities that confound the more loving amongst us.

But…to understand that all ‘evil’ is perpetrated by the walking wounded, that they are simply products of there own disconnect, pain, troubled soul and perhaps, mentally ill as well, helps to cloak the monster as something to pity not hate.

Also..( and this is a whole new can of worms ) IF there is such a thing as reincarnation, who are we to say that what we deem atrocious human behavior might not be but a spin on the karmic wheel for both the perpetrators AND the ‘victims’ ?

Perhaps the less evolved returning soul MUST experence more darkness and pain to ascend appropriately, and perhaps the victims willingly choose to be the the sacrificial lambs for anothers spiritual evolution.

In many ways this is the premise for trusting that everything is indeed, ‘perfect’, when all other explainations of mind fail to give us a satisfying answer that ego can latch onto to explain the inexplicable.

I dunno..but, more food for thought. :-)

I think this is where the concept of free will comes into play…the usual dichotomies…do we CHOOSE our behaviors, actions, thoughts and deeds, or are they predestined?

If one goes with the non-dual approach then no, it’s already a done deal, beyond our comprehension maybe, but..who’s to say that this orchestra of life is not already a play that has a pre-determined script?

Of course this line of thought is abhorrent to ego, which wants to beleve it is the master of it’s own destiny. lol

If you really wish to boggle your mind study Adviata Vendanta and other non-dual schools of thought

Talk about a mind fuck! haha

Totally shreds the ‘rational’ mind, but quite a liberating concept as well. ;-)

Coloma (47193

)“Great Answer” (2

)

Reincarnation is as believable as heaven/hell to me though. Sounds nice, but I’ve seen no true evidence. I would have to reason that if reincarnation exists for humans, it does for non-humans as well. Which is possible I guess, but again I’m not going to live my life as though it’s true when it could just be another illusion.

But I hear you on the other ideas. As you and I (and others) have found, the best we can do to enjoy life is appreciate it as clearly as possible. In fact yesterday I was doing some mundane work (hanging siding) and kept reminding myself to not “wander in the static zone” as you’d stated. Always a good idea, keeps the mind fresh and content. I just need a reminder like that occasionally.

I’ve read Tolle (Stillness Speaks) as you’ve mentioned and loved it. I’m also a fan of Krishnamurti. I’ll check out the Vendanta stuff some time, thanks.

cockswain (15276

)“Great Answer” (2

)