Ha ha, I’m the same way. Twilight Princess, Skyward Sword, Ocarina and Majora on the Virtual Console.
My son is apeshit for the Mario games. To me, though, Mario is all about competition between Mario and Luigi, and the new games in which they’re supposed to work together are just annoying. It’s incredibly distracting to have two (or three or four!) other people stealing your Fire Flowers and throwing turtles at you and pushing you into holes. Super Mario Galaxy 2 is fun. The first one is meh.
I know people who REALLY REALLY love the Resident Evil series. I have three RE games, but I haven’t bothered to try them out yet. I’m not much of a first-person type player. I want puzzles, not hand-eye stuff.