I remember when my parents finally let my best friend and I watch The Exorcist, they warned us, very seriously, about how horrifying it was. We were laughing our asses off most of the way through – which surprised them, to say the least.
I like scary movies, not gory movies, so when I saw The Others when I was younger, a lot of it scared the crap out of me. I’m usually let down by most horror movies in general – old or new. I think I’m too desensitized to actually be scared of most of the old ones, and the new ones are just too disgusting and gory.
There is an old one that I always forget the name of which I watched with a group of peers that all of us actually liked, though, and we genuinely thought it was creepy – which surprised all of us. It was about a boy in an old, huge house… and I think it had something to do with an attic?