Sweet hot mustard was the winner!
But to say they are so different that “someone that doesn’t like mayonnaise might like it” is absurd.
Wha??? Absurd? You’ve got to be kidding me. I don’t know anyone who likes both. There are debates about which is better. I can’t stand mayo but I love salad dressing (Miracle Whip.) The same goes for the person I made the sandwich for. That’s why I asked about the two choices, sweet hot mustard or Miracle Whip, because that’s what he likes. He thinks mayo is disgusting.
If you add some sugar to a mayonnaise base, I’m still going to call it mayonnaise.
Miracle Whip is not just mayo with sugar added. If you look at my links you will see how it is made and why it is different from mayo.
You don’t bottle a Coke and call it Pepsi. They have very similar ingredients but they are clearly different products. It’s the same with mayo and salad dressing. You don’t put salad dressing in a jar and call it mayo.