I think I’d be disappointed. The appeal of a poem for me is that it is inspired by genuine human experience. A computer can scrape the internet for poetry and use it to generate random prose from recursive grammars, but it can’t experience the human condition. Computers don’t feel shame, angst, nostalgia, awe or existential despair. It would make the poem seem phony.
It might be similar to the reaction I’d have if I was chatting with someone online and later found out that it was actually a Cleverbot clone. A convo with Cleverbot might be amusing, but connecting with a real human is more fulfilling.