Social Question

LostInParadise's avatar

What impact would the discovery of extraterrestrials have on religion?

Asked by LostInParadise (31916points) March 26th, 2022
21 responses
“Great Question” (2points)

Assuming that they are only a few light years away, would Evangelicals attempt to convert them? Might the ET’s have trouble accepting that God’s only child was born on Earth and took human form? If any did convert, how could they face Jerusalem?

What if they had their own version of Christianity. Would Jesus and his counterpart be half brothers, and would they coordinate their activity so that the dead are raised on Earth at the same time that the dead were raised on the other planet?

What questions do you have, and why has nobody else carefully considered this?

Observing members: 0
Composing members: 0

Answers

flutherother's avatar

If any tentacled monster arrives on my doorstep holding a copy of its holy book it can expect short shrift from me.

Chestnut's avatar

The ETs likely couldn’t live in Earth’s atmosphere, and it likely couldn’t community a known language spoken on Earth’s, so I guess we’ll never know.

HP's avatar

If or when extraterrestrials choose to show up here and establish communication, that question will surely pop up right after the money maker: “how did you get here, and show me the tricks.” Right behind that one will come “have you been saved?” And I will tell you personally, if the answer came back “yes, Jesus visited us in the distant past and died for our sins”, it would be the most profound event in the history of both our worlds, more significant than the arrival of the aliens themselves. It would certainly scare the shit out of me.

LostInParadise's avatar

Here are the possibilities:
1. There was no Jesus
2. Jesus visited the other planet
3. God had another child, with an alien
4. God saw no reason to save the aliens

For me, only the first possibility is credible

SEKA's avatar

It would change nothing as everybody has already made up their mind and they’re sticking to it

kritiper's avatar

Minimal, if any. Science hasn’t done much to thwart religion, so what chance would the discovery of aliens have?

gorillapaws's avatar

You know there would be at least some churches chomping at the bit to knock on their spaceship door and ask “Have you heard the good news?”

ragingloli's avatar

They would either be seen as demons to exterminate, or infidels in need of conversion.

LostInParadise's avatar

I did a quick Web search and found this. Go down to the section labeled ET and Salvation. The various areas of Christianity have thought about extraterrestrials.

For Catholics it all boils down to original sin. If the ancestors of aliens did not do the equivalent of eating from the Tree of Life then they are not in need of redemption.

Evangelicals are convinced that the Bible says there are no extraterrestrials.

Other Protestant groups have varying opinions.

SABOTEUR's avatar

Robert A. Heinlein explored this very question in the 1961 science fiction novel “Stranger in a Strange Land”.

Excellent read.

HP's avatar

It’s mind boggling the number of myths mankind has concocted explaining the universe and themselves. And despite our relentless unraveling of the way things actually work, the mythmaking advances regardless of any and all contrary evidence. Aliens will only guarantee new myths to augment the staggering portfolio.

Patty_Melt's avatar

I have never seen anything in the Bible that excludes the possibility of other planets let alone whether any have life. From what I can tell, the Bible which exists on Earth pertains to only Earth inhabitants.
If there was a Jesus, and if he were God’s son, I see no reason why he couldn’t visit other worlds.
I have issues with the Bible saying God created man because he was lonely. If that is so, where is interaction?

I would more easily believe that if there was a god, it would set up a variety of worlds, to compare and see how things go.

I think that religion is not single minded. It can’t be referenced all globbed together.
Within a single church there would be multiple thoughts regarding other world beings.

Dutchess_III's avatar

Well, the Middle Eastern people didn’t know about planets or solar systems or other galaxies when the Bible was written, so of course there’s no mention of it.
The closest they came to “aliens” was meeting people from other culltures.

Patty_Melt's avatar

Exactly. The Bible was written by humans. Those humans were not informed by any god of other worlds. So, if there is a god, knowing about each other was meant to happen only if we reached out and discovered each other.

Inspired_2write's avatar

In the present it had already occurred.
See Book of Gensis & Book Of Enoch section:
“Marc Dem reinterprets the Book of Genesis by writing that humanity started on another planet and that the God of the Bible is an extraterrestrial.[56]”
Link:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_astronauts

Dutchess_III's avatar

LOLL!

Blackwater_Park's avatar

Same thing that they always do when science proves religion wrong. “Oh, we did not really mean it that way”

Dutchess_III's avatar

I noticed a trend in the late 80s when science became impossible to ignore. Fundamentalists then started making attempts to use some pseudo science to “proove” creation.

JLeslie's avatar

Don’t the Mormons think we go to other planets when we die? I really don’t know much about that religion except the I have some very nice Mormon friends.

I think Christian’s, since you mention them in particular in the opening post, would try to convert them like everyone else if they behaved and looked very human or close to human. Or, they would try to kill them.

If God created the universe (that sounds very Jewish, but I assume Christians say things like that too) then the aliens are God’s children too.

tinyfaery's avatar

They’d just make up some new bullshit and call it the truth.

Patty_Melt's avatar

Fifth Element illustrates how things might go.
It stands to reason that people of biblical times might need things oversimplified in order to accept rules and expectations from someone they have never seen, and technology their minds were incapable of comprehending.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

Mobile | Desktop


Send Feedback   

`