You should avoid painting the feelings of an entire country toward a group of people with a broad brush. The truth is, Americans feel many things towards Muslims. Some hate them, some love them, some are Muslims themselves, some are apathetic, some don’t even know there is a religion called Islam.
Personally, I judge based on the individual. I like the Muslims I go to school with. I hate the Muslims who cut off girls’ noses and the ones that rule certain countries with an iron fist. Do these characteristics come from the certain individual’s religion, per se, or other factors? A little bit of both. I can’t really say.