I don’t hate it. If it were between reading posts that don’t address the question and eating cottage cheese, I’d choose the latter. I hate cottage cheese.
Unhelpful responses can get annoying, but they can be figuratively batted away like a fly. I’d much prefer that the person posting the question gave more thought into properly wording the question to fit exactly what it is that they are seeking to answer and not something vague, misleading (unless intentional, of course), and lacking detail in the description.
I understand that we all don’t have the time to read through all of the responses. If I don’t, I book mark it for a later time when I can get back to it. If someone has already responded the way I would have, I just mark it with a GA and don’t contribute. No point in making the thread any longer than it already is, unless there is an additional idea or suggestion.
One thing I absolutely always do is look for any additional posts from the OP. Some have added details that negate or change the response I was mentally crafting.