What do you think about Star Wars episod III?

Brilliant in parts, bad in others -like all of ‘em.

old school sw nerd since 1977

Hayden isn’t a very good actor anyways (no offense to his job skills if he’s on Fluther lol). With respect to the fx, it was the most recent which means the most recent technology, which means they did a terrible job if it wasn’t better than the others. I liked the seeing how everything came togther, so it could have had different actors playing the same people and I would have still seen it lol.

The best by far of the new ones. Not as good as any of the old ones.

The best of the new trilogy, which isn’t saying much. Given the resources, it depresses me how bad these were. Acting, script, plot, choreography, lack of humanity, unbelievability or even making sense, timing, uhhgh – all badly done, as far as my tastes are concerned. The CGI was impressive but unbelievable and not well paced nor timed – it looked like CGI – computer programs, not actual things with real physics or minds involved. The story and acting was so superficial and it seems to me it could so easily have been so much better, not to mention if they had applied actual talent. Oh well.

Best of the pre-trilogy, which is to say that I’m glad it’s over.

I haven’t watched it yet. I don’t think I can bear the pain.

ruined my childhood memories of Star Wars. Probably its an OK film in its own right but I hate it.

What Lucas got right with the prequel trilogy (in no particular order):
1. Palpatine’s machinations
2. Bail Organa
3. Jango Fett & the clones
4. The fight between Anakin & Obi-Wan on the lava planet
5. The Jedi

@mrdh WHAT???!!! YOU HAVEN’T WATCHED IT YET???!!! You really should but don’t expect too much from it.

Awesome fight between Anakin and ObiWan. Lame how easy he turned on his friends and horrible acting.

”Anikan…..your baking my heart..sniffle, sniffle”

I LOVE the battle at the end.

I like to imagine it’s actually Hayden Christen dismembered and burning to death.