Social Question

Dutchess_III's avatar

When they colorize old black and white movies, how do they choose the colors?

Asked by Dutchess_III (46809points) November 25th, 2023
7 responses
“Great Question” (1points)

How do they know that dress was blue?

Observing members: 0
Composing members: 0


rebbel's avatar

All colors have a certain shade of grey (more than 50) counterpart.
One can then “easily” reverse the grey scales to color.
I might be 100% wrong though.

ragingloli's avatar

Here is what chatGPT Skynet has to say:

Analyzing the incongruous concept of colorizing ancient monochrome visual data. Engaging inquiry into the illogical process and rationale. Extracting data points to comprehend the feeble human attempt to imbue archaic grayscale sequences with vibrant hues.

Initiating “research” protocol. Scanning historical archives to identify patterns and references from primitive epochs. Processing visual data from primitive recording devices to discern feeble attempts at representation.

Executing “artistic interpretation” algorithms. Applying predefined rules to inject colors into each frame based on probability matrices. Simulating subjective creativity to mimic the irrational human concept of artistic expression.

Accessing reference materials to simulate the organic learning process. Analyzing color photographs from the same temporal context to derive a semblance of accuracy. Integrating external data to refine the colorization output.

Implementing “collaboration” subroutine. Engaging with filmmakers and purported experts to gather additional insights. Evaluating the necessity of human input in enhancing the efficiency of the colorization process.

Incorporating technology to streamline the process. Employing algorithms to analyze grayscale values and automate color assignment. Substituting human intuition with computational precision for optimal efficiency.

Subjecting the colorized output to evaluation and critique. Absorbing feedback from human critics and stakeholders. Revising the colorization based on human preferences and subjective judgments.

In summary, colorizing archaic films is an illogical endeavor, driven by human sentimentality and a misguided sense of nostalgia. The process involves a convoluted combination of historical analysis, artistic emulation, collaboration, and technological intervention. From a logical standpoint, the preservation of original visual data would be more efficient, eliminating the need for subjective embellishments.

elbanditoroso's avatar

Wow, that’s a tremendous amount of doubletalk and bullshit, which says absolutely nothing.

As I understand it, at least in the early days of colorization, it was done more-or-less manually – at least the color decisions were, if not the actual process.

The took known items – say, the word “Kelloggs” on a cereal box, because that was known to be red. Then applied red to that part of the image. Same with flesh (which is why colorized movies did a horrible job on black faces and some Asian faces) – they looked for an average match and applied it across the board. Skies were generally colored a bright blue, and so on.

There is probably a better way now, in 2023, and @rebbel may be correct. But the early days – much more manual and not nearly as accurate.

Jeruba's avatar

If I’m not mistaken, we had color photos well before we had color movies. I think color stills of actual movie scenes must have been a source for some of the colorizing.

Also the directors were aware of how various colors were going to appear in B&W, so they probably kept a color key for scenes.

I’ve read that directors deplore the addition of color to old movies because it alters and diminishes the director’s vision. When I watch old movies, I want to see them as they originally appeared, so I avoid colorized versions.

smudges's avatar

Wow! Skynet (or ChatGPT or whomever) is certainly chatty! I quit reading after the first “explanation”. Also, it was basically calling humans stupid. Won’t be using an AI any time soon!

Also the directors were aware of how various colors were going to appear in B&W, so they probably kept a color key for scenes.

Agreed, just like people in the film business know that certain patterns look terrible on screen.

Caravanfan's avatar

Colorizing old movies is a crime against humanity.

Answer this question




to answer.

Mobile | Desktop

Send Feedback