There is no right or wrong, as long as you have filled out the W2 honestly and correctly. The question is whether you want a refund at the end of the year, or to pay some taxes at the end of the year. Financially it is better to have to pay a little, because you get to use that money all year, preferably by saving and earning interest, instead of the government holding on to it. On the other hand, letting the government hold onto is kind of like forced savings, but without any interest. I for one shoot for a refund, and this year my salary changed and I failed completely and will have to sign a rather large check for the city, the state, and the feds. Ugh.
Oh, I guess there could be a right and wrong if your employer did the math wrong, but that’s not likely, and still is only going to affect the amount of your refund or payment at year end.
Also, off the top of my head those numbers seem about right, maybe a little high, but that’s just based on what I’m used to seeing.